231 Park Ave - Elijah Keighley Home

This lot was created by subdividing a large lot in 1888, which Elijah Keighley bought for $400. This vernacular house is also a gabled “L” and shows shingle design influence, having horizontal, vertical, and imbricated siding. Keighley was a miller, who apparently built another house in the neighborhood. A 1900 directory, however, shows him living here. At that time the address was 12 Park Avenue.